The Logos Scripture · The Book of Russell

On the First Cause

The Book of Russell 1 · Written by himself, from his lectures, essays, prison writing and autobiography

Bertrand Russell, born at Trellech in Wales in 1872, died in Wales in 1970 at ninety-seven. Both his parents were dead before he was four, and his grandmother raised him. With Whitehead he wrote the three volumes of Principia Mathematica, meaning to set arithmetic on logic. In 1901 he found a contradiction in his own scheme and wrote to Frege about it; Frege, whose life’s work was then at the printer, added a paragraph at the end saying the foundation of his book had been shaken. In 1916 he was fined for defending a conscientious objector and Cambridge dismissed him; in 1918 an article put him in prison for six months, where he finished a book on the philosophy of mathematics. In 1940 the City College of New York appointed him and a court revoked the appointment on the ground of his views on morals. He took the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1950. In 1955 he and Einstein signed the manifesto urging the nations to give up such weapons (cf. The Book of Einstein). In 1961, at eighty-nine, he went to prison for a week for inciting civil disobedience. This volume rests on what he wrote himself, not on another man’s record of him. He did not believe and did not hide it: the lecture he gave in 1927 is called Why I Am Not a Christian. What this volume brings is something the scripture did not have: a man taking back in public what he had said, and showing the working of the retraction (chapter three). There are men here who changed (cf. The Book of Franklin), but none who ran the same reason twice and got two different answers.

1.1When I was a boy I read one question, and it let me out of the argument from the First Cause.
1.2The argument runs: everything has a cause; follow the causes back and there must be something with no cause of its own, and that is God.
1.3At eighteen I read Mill’s autobiography and found the question his father taught him (cf. The Book of John Stuart Mill).
1.4The question is: then who made God?
1.5That one sentence. The First Cause argument came apart in my hands and never went back together.
1.6For if everything must have a cause, then God must have one too.
1.7And if one thing may have no cause, that thing may as well be the world, and need not be God.
1.8The argument does not prove that there is a God. It proves only that a man may stop wherever he likes and say: no further.
1.9Where he stops is chosen by him, not by the argument.
1.10I do not say this to make fun of those who believe.
1.11I once wanted there to be a First Cause. Wanting there to be, and there being, are two things.
1.12An argument that holds only while you hope it will hold is not an argument. It is a wish.
1.13Much of what I have done in my life came out of that one question: then who made that one?
The Logos Scripture →

中文 English 日本語 Español Français Deutsch