The Logos Scripture · The Book of Lincoln

On my having suspended the writ

The Book of Lincoln 3 · Written by himself, from the letters, the messages to Congress, the Emancipation Proclamation, and the Second Inaugural

Abraham Lincoln, born 1809 in Kentucky, died 15 April 1865 in Washington, killed by an assassin, aged fifty-six. In his youth he worked as a farm hand, a boatman and a shop clerk, and taught himself law. He entered the Illinois legislature in 1834 and served one term in the House of Representatives from 1847. In 1858 he debated Douglas seven times, lost the Senate seat and became famous. In 1860 he was elected the sixteenth President; eleven southern states left, and the war ran four years and killed more than six hundred thousand. The Emancipation Proclamation took effect on 1 January 1863. He was returned in 1864, was sworn in a second time on 4 March 1865, received the surrender of the southern army on 9 April, and was shot five days later. This volume rests on what he wrote himself: the letter to Greeley of 22 August 1862, the message to Congress of 4 July 1861, the Emancipation Proclamation, the Charleston debate of 1858, the letter to Hodges of 4 April 1864, and the Second Inaugural of 4 March 1865. The sequence in chapter one is as stated: the draft was read to the cabinet on 22 July and Seward advised waiting for a victory; Greeley’s piece appeared on 19 August and Lincoln answered on the 22nd; the preliminary Proclamation was issued on 22 September. The sequence in chapter three is likewise as stated: Congress was summoned on 15 April, the writ was suspended on 27 April, Congress sat on 4 July, and on 3 March 1863 it passed an act confirming the power. What this volume adds is something the scripture did not have: a man who said less than he did. Most of those gathered here suffered for saying the true thing. This one understated what he wanted, in order to be able to accomplish it. The Order holds that this must be read on two levels. He did not say the opposite of the truth, and the last line of the letter still carried his real wish. But the road is a dangerous one, and by that reasoning any deceiver may call himself a man playing a long game. So chapters one and five must be read together: the man who understated in order to win refused, on the day of victory, to overstate by a single word. The measure is in the comparison. The Order records where he cuts against this scripture and hides none of it. First, the words of 1858 quoted at 4.2 are as he said them. This volume does not delete them, and neither did he. Second, 3.13 is as stated: after the first suspension he extended it across the country, and those confined ran into the thousands; in 1863 Vallandigham, who had sat in Congress, was arrested and banished over a speech. Third, a year after his death the Supreme Court held in Milligan that military trials are unconstitutional where the civil courts are open, and that ruling has stood. The Order takes this man not because he never crossed a line, but because after he crossed it the road remained open — those who sued him, argued against him and judged him were none of them shut up. This agrees with what Popper says (see The Book of Popper 5.10).

3.1In April 1861 the South fired on the fort.
3.2Baltimore rioted. The railway was cut and the telegraph was cut. Between the capital and the North one road was left, from Philadelphia to Washington.
3.3If that road went, Washington was surrounded.
3.4On the fifteenth of April I called Congress into special session, to sit on the fourth of July.
3.5On the twenty-seventh of April I authorised the commanding general to suspend the writ of habeas corpus along that one road.
3.6Mark the order of it. I called the Congress first and suspended afterwards. The Congress had not yet come, and I could not wait for it to come.
3.7The matter went to court. Chief Justice Taney held that the power to suspend belongs to Congress and not to the President.
3.8What the Constitution says is that the privilege of the writ shall not be suspended unless in cases of rebellion or invasion the public safety may require it.
3.9It says when it may be suspended. It does not say who may suspend it.
3.10On the fourth of July the Congress came, and I gave them my reasoning.
3.11I asked them: are all the laws but one to go unexecuted, and the government itself go to pieces, lest that one be violated?
3.12I do not withdraw that question. But I know it can be picked up and used for other purposes.
3.13Later I extended the suspension across the whole country, to all who discouraged enlistment or gave aid to the rebels. Those confined ran into the thousands.
3.14I set that down here too. To leave it out would be dishonest.
3.15On the third of March 1863 Congress passed an act giving the power to the President. I acted first and the Congress confirmed it after.
3.16The whole of it was done where men could see it, and throughout there were men suing me, cursing me, and writing against me.
3.17I do not say I was wholly right. I say this: I did not close that road.
The Logos Scripture →

中文 English 日本語 Español Français Deutsch